The Federal Justice Minister, Stefanie Hubig of the Social Democratic Party (SPD), has stipulated conditions for the nationwide implementation of data analysis software from the U.S. company Palantir. Minister Hubig acknowledged significant public reservations regarding the technology’s use.
Speaking to the Handelsblatt, Hubig expressed concerns shared by citizens, including fears that sensitive personal data could be shared with foreign entities. She also noted apprehension about Germany potentially developing an overreliance on a single vendor. “If these reservations cannot be fully addressed, it would be difficult to justify deploying this software” she commented.
Hubig nevertheless emphasized the government’s commitment to equipping law enforcement and security agencies with modern tools to proactively address threats and effectively combat crime. She stated that such modernization reinforces public trust in the rule of law. However, the Justice Minister stressed the need for “particular caution” when it comes to tools that automate data analysis, highlighting their potential impact on fundamental rights. She insisted their use must be firmly rooted in legal frameworks that align with constitutional principles.
Currently, German federal law lacks a specific regulation to govern such applications. However, an agreement has been reached with the conservative Union faction to create the necessary legal basis. Hubig stressed the importance of adhering to guidelines established by the Federal Constitutional Court, particularly its rulings concerning similar regulations in the states of Hessen and Hamburg.
According to Hubig, automated data analysis by authorities should only be considered in cases involving the investigation of serious crimes or the prevention of substantial dangers. Furthermore, legal authorization must be “sufficiently precise” to ensure transparency and accountability.