The Lufthansa’s recent decision to integrate Starlink’s satellite internet access into its in-flight entertainment system is sparking a debate within Germany, raising concerns about technological dependence and prompting calls for a distinctly European alternative. Bundesdigitalminister Karsten Wildberger, from the CDU, has publicly voiced his concern, emphasizing the necessity of fostering homegrown solutions within the European Union.
Speaking to “Welt” Wildberger acknowledged Starlink’s current crucial role, citing its significance in supporting Ukraine, but underscored the inherent risks of relying on a single, privately-owned provider, particularly one controlled by Elon Musk. He posited that the superior performance of Starlink’s system, when compared to European competitors, highlights the urgency for sustained European investment and development in satellite services. “We must ask ourselves: where is the European alternative?” he stated.
The concerns extend beyond mere technological proficiency. The SPD parliamentary group has already issued a warning against the potential pitfalls of an over-reliance on Musk’s technology and business practices. Their criticisms highlight a deeper anxiety regarding the influence of a single, powerful entity over critical infrastructure.
Wildberger’s push for European development isn’t a new initiative. He has repeatedly championed increased dynamism within the German technology sector, advocating for a proactive role for the state as an “anchor customer” to bolster domestic innovation. While recognizing the current market landscape, the Minister’s comments signify a strategic shift towards reducing dependence on foreign providers and securing a more autonomous future for European digital infrastructure. The debate underscores a growing political sensitivity surrounding data sovereignty and the geopolitical implications of relying on technologies dominated by entities outside of the EU’s jurisdiction.