A concerning decline in data sharing from X, formerly Twitter, is significantly hindering German law enforcement’s ability to investigate hate crimes, according to a recently released internal assessment by the Federal Criminal Police Office (BKA). The assessment, reported by “Der Spiegel”, reveals a drastic reduction in the platform’s cooperation with the Central Reporting Centre for Online Criminal Content (ZMI), a crucial division responsible for analyzing potentially illegal online activity.
Previously, in 2024, the ZMI successfully received requested data in over 80% of cases relating to suspected hate crimes, including incitement to hatred, insults directed at politicians and postings that endorse criminal acts or display symbols of unconstitutional organizations. However, data availability plummeted to just around 33% between April 10th and May 31st, 2025.
The BKA’s analysis explicitly accuses X of “actively obstructing” the investigative work of German authorities. Without access to platform data, investigations are frequently being closed due to the inability to identify potential suspects, effectively shielding perpetrators of online hate speech and criminal endorsement from accountability.
The assessment scrutinizes 700 specific requests submitted by the ZMI concerning X posts flagged for potential criminal activity. The dwindling cooperation marks a stark contrast to previous collaborative efforts and raises crucial questions regarding Elon Musk’s commitment to upholding legal frameworks within Germany.
Initial inquiries by “Der Spiegel” regarding the reduced data sharing have reportedly gone unanswered by X, further amplifying concerns about a deliberate retraction of support for law enforcement. This shift in policy carries significant implications for Germany’s ability to combat online extremism and protect vulnerable groups targeted by hate speech, prompting demands for clarification and renewed dedication to data transparency from X’s leadership. The situation underscores the increasingly complex and politically charged relationship between social media platforms and national law enforcement agencies in the digital age.