Germany is reportedly moving forward with the development of a marine-capable laser defense system for its armed forces, awarding a contract to arms manufacturer Rheinmetall without a public tender. The development, valued at approximately €390 million, aims to deliver three demonstration units by the end of the decade.
According to reports, the German government intends to utilize a direct contract mechanism to commission the laser system’s development, a decision sparking debate given the existence of competing systems already available in the market. Some observers suggest that alternative solutions, such as those offered by Australian firm Electro Optic Systems (EOS), which has subsidiaries across Europe, possess superior capabilities. EOS operates a 100-kilowatt laser system with a range exceeding five kilometers and has reportedly expressed willingness to increase its output to 120 kilowatt – double that of Rheinmetall’s proposed system – while offering the technology at half the price.
The German Federal Office of Equipment, Information Technology and Usage of the Bundeswehr has declined to offer specifics, citing an ongoing procurement process. “A tendering procedure is currently underway for a laser weapon system intended for use by the Navy. Therefore, we cannot provide more detailed information regarding the questions raised at this time” a spokesperson stated.
Concerns regarding the procurement process have been raised by members of the German parliament, particularly regarding the potential for preferential treatment and the bypassing of competitive bidding. Green Party parliamentarian Sebastian Schäfer has characterized the decision as diverting funds from the United States towards Rheinmetall, questioning the transparency and potential for hidden subsidies. “It cannot be that Germany secretly subsidizes projects like this” Schäfer commented. He emphasized the importance of strictly adhering to open and competitive procurement procedures, particularly given the substantial budget allocated to defense acquisitions.