A leading migration researcher, Gerald Knaus, has declared the concept of returns a failure. In an interview with the “Stern” podcast, he expressed his skepticism about the German government’s plan to continue with the policy, despite a recent court ruling deeming it unlawful.
The Berlin Administrative Court had ruled on Monday that the return of three Somalis by the Federal Police was unlawful. Knaus was taken aback by the announcement from Federal Interior Minister Alexander Dobrindt, who intends to stick to the controversial concept. “At some point, the SPD, which appoints the Justice Minister, will have to ask how the Federal Police can be sent to do something that is obviously unlawful” Knaus said.
Knaus, who is familiar with the practical aspects of migration, stated that he knows of no one who believes the concept will work. He suggested that the government instead focus on secure third-country agreements, similar to the EU-Turkey deal, which have already reduced numbers and been presented as a success in election campaigns. The European Commission had presented proposals two weeks prior, which, if implemented, would make such agreements legally possible, Knaus noted.
According to Knaus, the SPD, CDU and CSU in the European Parliament should now work to expedite the process. “Most in the EU want this” he said. “Then, one could start negotiations and making offers as soon as possible. As quickly as possible.