The President of the German Caritasverband, Eva Maria Welskop-Deffaa, has voiced strong criticism regarding the German government’s proposed “Aktivrente” scheme. Describing the initiative as a “very expensive tax gift for well-situated baby boomers” she questioned its fairness and potential impact on the social security system.
The planned legislation would allow retirees to earn up to €2,000 per month tax-free. Welskop-Deffaa highlighted a perceived disparity, contrasting this benefit with the situation faced by individuals like caregivers with young children who must pay full taxes on additional earnings, even when necessary for essential family support. “A caregiver striving to supplement their income to provide for their children is treated differently than a retiree” she stated.
Amid broader discussions surrounding proposed social reforms, Welskop-Deffaa urged policymakers to moderate the increasingly emotive tone of the debate. She emphasized the importance of safeguarding the German social state, warning that the current discourse risks undermining it, particularly given the readiness of opposition parties to exploit vulnerabilities.
Recognizing the accelerating demographic shifts, Welskop-Deffaa stressed the urgent need for sustainable solutions that transcend generational divides. She called for a more cautious and collaborative approach from politicians, advising against premature announcements and inflammatory rhetoric, emphasizing that effective responses can only be achieved through intergenerational cooperation.